A Bull Market in Phony Naziana
Ever the dictator the last days of Hitler in April 1945, when the defeated dictator wrote his will, married his mistress Eva Braun and put a bullet through his brain the a 7.65-mm Walther pistol, phony Hitleriana —including the will, the marriage certificate and the pistol—have flooded the worldwide market for Nazi memorabilia. In 1981, for example, an avid collector asked the noted West German historian Werner Maser to authenticate what he claimed was the suicide pistol of Maser last week: "I told him there existed a whole suitcase full of Hitler of firearms, all forged with Hitler's initials and the correct number of Hitler's pistol permit." The "collector" was Stern Reporter Gerd Heidemann.
Though Heidemann's Hitler diaries have proved to be the most audacious of all the Third Reich forgeries so far, other major scams have often bemused or confounded the experts. The first large-scale postwar forgery surfaced in 1947: a diary allegedly kept by Eva Braun during her affair with Hitler. According to Maser, Trenker, of the authors turned out to be a prominent film actor, Luis Trenker, who had known Braun. Right-wing Author David Irving ruefully recalls that in 1973 he nearly bought diaries purportedly written by Admiral Wilhelm Canaris, Nazi Germany's chief of military intelligence until 1944. On the scent of sensational revelations, Irving and the British publishers William Collins Sons deposited $120,000 in a West German bank for the privilege of examining a twelve-page extract from the typewritten documents, which bore a signature that was allegedly Canaris'. When tested by a London laboratory, the signature proved to have been written with a ball point pen, an instrument that came into use in Germany after Canaris was executed on Hitler's orders in 1945.
A former archivist of the Nazi Party, August Priesack, last year offered Irving 800 photostats of Nazi documents, including parts of a diary supposedly kept by Hitler and a letter from Rudolf Hess to Hitler about his projected 1941 flight to Scotland. Irving brought 400 pages to Britain, but after scrutinizing them pronounced them forgeries. Irving now believes that the Stern 1930s and those he studied last year came from the same source, though he had earlier considered the Stern material to be authentic.
Maser and other specialists believe that a network of fanatic German Nazis in Latin America have conspired to spread forged documents designed to white wash their Führer and revive interest in the Nazi period. According to Maser, there is close cooperation between the Nazis in Latin America and forgers in Communist East Germany who are producing Hitler-era material that is intended to create bad feelings among the NATO partners while it brings in much needed dollars and other hard currency.
Charles Hamilton, the U.S.'s largest dealer in Nazi mementos, spots one or two fakes a month among the thousands of Third Reich items he handles every year. Many are signed photos of Hitler, which, if genuine, are worth from $350 to $ 1,000 to collectors. Such photo forgeries are often simple to detect because Hitler rarely signed a picture unless it had been taken by his personal photographer, Heinrich Hoffmann, who stamped a distinctive seal on his photos.
Even more common are forged Hitler inscriptions in books, usually Mein Kampf. Careless forgers occasionally fail to research the relationship between Hitler and the alleged recipients of the books, thus committing detectable errors like using inappropriately flowery language. For the forgers, potential rewards are high. A genuinely inscribed two-volume first edition of Mein Kampf sells for $10,000. A handwritten letter from Hitler to a top Nazi leader can fetch as much as $25,000.
Will the exposure of the phony Hitler diaries and other forgeries of Nazi mementos deter buyers? Hamilton thinks not. "Evil seems sexy," he observes. The world's estimated 50,000 collectors of Naziana, he says, find "the monstrosity and evil of Nazism to be strangely exciting.
January 3, 2001
Sickos and forgers
While the interest of many collectors is harmless, however, there remains a distinctly unsavoury side to the whole Third Reich souvenir industry.
"Unfortunately there are an awful lot of sickos around," says Quarrie. "People who collect the stuff because they feel an ideological affinity with it."
Dutch army surplus supplier Willem, 36 -- he refuses to give his surname for fear of reprisals -- has first hand experience of such characters.
Three months ago, while at a militaria fair in Belgium, he remonstrated with a man walking around in full SS regalia only to be beaten up by four of the man's friends.
"A lot of these people are pretty nasty," he says. "It can be an extremely aggressive scene. Not everyone who collects this sort of thing is a Nazi, but many of them definitely have leanings that way.
"And even if they don't, it still seems indecent to want to own something associated with a regime that slaughtered so many innocent people, and so recently."
There is also a problem with forgeries, with most experts agreeing that a substantial proportion of the items on the market are fake.
"The industry is dominated by fake stuff," says Nigel Hay of Milweb.com, a portal for militaria collectors and dealers. "During the 1950s people in East Germany started forging Nazi memorabilia and it's been flooding the market ever since."
"You have to be careful," agrees Quarrie. "Unsuspecting people can spend a lot of money on something that was knocked up in someone's shed last week."
Despite this, however, and the efforts of certain governments to clamp down on the trade in such materials, the interest in all things Nazi remains undiminished, especially in Britain and the U.S.
"There is a genuine historical interest in this sort of thing," says Michael Whine, of the Board of Deputies of British Jews, "And to that extent we have no real objection to people buying and selling it.
"Where we do object, however, is when it is used to promote or glorify Nazism and the ideals of the Third Reich. That's when it becomes dangerous."
October 14, 2006
Polish firms carve out niche with Nazi uniforms
Andrzej Frankowski runs one of handful of companies in Poland that make copies of Nazi uniforms. Firm sells mainly to film companies and history buffs, but some fear uniforms he offers via internet may be falling into hands of far-right extremists.
Andrzej Frankowski holds up a Nazi-era German army jacket and says the officer who wore it must have fought in the hot deserts of North Africa.
"You can tell by the thin fabric it has been made from," Frankowski says, running his hand over the faded olive green jacket.
It's an original that he uses as a model for the replicas meticulously crafted in his cramped workshop.
Frankowski runs one of a handful of companies in Poland that make copies of Nazi uniforms - for many Poles a surprising business in a country subjected to six years of brutal Nazi occupation that cost millions of lives during World War II.
His firm sells mainly to film companies and history buffs, although some people fear that uniforms he offers via the internet may be falling into the hands of far-right extremists.
On one recent day, a few women in his workshop in the western city of Poznan hovered over sewing machines making copies of the uniforms worn by Poland's despised wartime occupiers. They also make related paraphernalia, including Nazi cuffbands saying "Der Fuehrer."
"This is my idea for business and for offering jobs to people," said Frankowski, 36. "I could also make Chinese uniforms, no problem, if only there were a demand for them."
The German invasion of Poland in 1939 started World War II, during which Poland lost more than 6 million citizens - half of them Jews. Today, bitterness toward Germany still resonates in day-to-day politics and among older Pole. Complete uniform sells for USD 820
Frankowski insists there is no ideology behind what he produces in his little work space, squeezed into an attic above a car repair shop that his family owns in a neighborhood of warehouses and empty lots.
He said the uniforms he makes - some 5,000 annually - include replicas of British, Polish, Russian and American army uniforms and are used in films and historical re-enactments, a popular activity for history buffs.
He says his clients come from Poland, Belgium, the Netherlands, Britain and the Czech Republic. A complete uniform sells for about USD 820, he said.
Officially, there is no market in Germany since displaying Nazi regalia is illegal there, but Frankowski said he buys originals at armaments fairs in the German cities of Bremen, Stuttgart and Kassel.
Boguslaw Woloszanski, a popular script writer of state-produced TV documentaries about the war, said businesses like Frankowski's help reconstruct history faithfully.
"You could not make a historic film or a re-enactment scene without them," said Woloszanski, who has bought historical uniforms from Hero Collection, another producer in Poznan.
Perhaps reflecting the sometimes strongly negative reaction to the work, Hero Collection declined to talk about its products. The company's Web sites says it has supplied uniforms for such movies as the Oscar-winning "The Pianist," the TV film "Hitler: The Rise of Evil" and the Italian movie "Karol, the Man Who Became the Pope."
To make uniforms requires great historic knowledge and accuracy, Woloszanski said.
Sept. 3, 2008
Polish Firm Investigated for Producing Nazi Memorabilia
Prosecutors in Poland have opened an investigation of a firm producing Nazi-era memorabilia for a buyer in Germany.
Polish prosecutors said Tuesday, Sept 2, that they have started investigating a jewelry firm producing Nazi memorabilia. The Internal Security Agency searched the company's headquarters, spokeswoman for the Polish prosecutor, Malgorzata Klaus, told the PAP news agency. The firm's headquarters was searched by the Internal Security Agency.
Among the items found in the raid were Nazi replicas including swastikas, military insignia and rings with skulls like those worn by Nazi Germany's SS troops. According to the Polska newspaper, the items were produced for a German citizen from the former East Germany. The distribution or wearing of Nazi-era symbols is banned in Germany.
"It is legal to produce such items for the needs of film producers or collectors," Klaus said.
Poland is Europe's biggest producer and exporter of Nazi memorabilia. Most of the items are sold to neo-Nazis in Germany or Scandinavia, Polska said. Buying Nazi symbols is illegal in those countries, but allowed in Poland. SS emblems and swastika armbands can be purchased at markets in Poland's larger cities.
Business is also booming on the Internet, with one Polish auction Web site offering some 600 items. A complete SS officer's uniform goes for 3,000 zloty ($1,400 or 890 euros), while iron crosses cost 15 zloty and are often sold in bulk, Polska said.
Polish law forbids promoting Nazi ideology, said Klaus, but not selling historic mementos or reproductions.
"But it is illegal to publicly promote a fascist state system," she said, adding that those convicted of publicly promoting fascism face a prison term up to two years.
April 27, 2008
Czech sales of Nazi memorabilia growing
Czech auction Web sites are offering thousands of Nazi-related items that have been growing in popularity.
For instance, Aukro.cz had 1,335 items in its “Germany 1933-1945” section on Wednesday.
“We have recently sold a Nazi dagger of the National Socialist Motor Corps for 80,000 crowns,” or $3,188, auction operator Oto Obdrzalek told the daily newspaper Mlada fronta Dnes Thursday.
Klara Kalibova, from the nongovernmental organization Tolerance and Civic Society, said neo-Nazis are among the buyers of the memorabilia.
“A Hitlerian wing has recently won in the extremist National Resistance movement and its members buy these items to strengthen their identity,” Kalibova said, referring to an extreme-right movement.
Some buyers indicate their support for neo-Nazi ideas with their nicknames, such as Fritz88 and Pavel88, using the two numbers symbolizing the Heil Hitler salute.
Oto Lustig, who runs the auction site Odklepnuto.cz , told Mlada fronta Dnes that Holocaust survivors often send him letters complaining about the sale of Nazi-related items.
A police officer specializing in right-wing extremism said the Czech police monitor the auction sites.
January 6, 2008
Collectors can find Iron Cross or uniform, but watch out for fake relics
The Nazi war medal looked so authentic it could fool an obedient soldier of the Third Reich. But the gimlet eye of F. Patt Anthony suspected a forgery.
Anthony, a Greensboro vendor of military relics, rotated the Iron Cross against the light, critically rubbing the metal underside with his thumb. He announced his verdict with a scowl.
"When you see this swiveling pin, always be suspicious. That's just typical of India and Pakistan and what they make today," Anthony declared Saturday. "I'm a doubting Thomas, and you need to be in this business."
Anthony is holding court at the State Fairgrounds this weekend, selling military memorabilia and dispensing friendly counsel at the Old North State Antique Gun and Military Antiques Show. The traveling flea market features enough uniforms, canteens, compasses, lighters, lanterns, watches, medals, helmets, bayonets and firearms to stock a military museum and outfit a unit to defend it.
"There is a buyer and collector for everything," said vendor George Walls Jr., a retired Marine general from Cary. "The hardest thing is getting the buyer and the item in the same place and the same time. When you can do that, it's magic." Or flim-flam, if you're not careful.
In the world of antiques, replicas and forgeries abound, especially as demand drives up prices. Fellow vendors defer to Anthony as the high priest of military memorabilia, and collectors pass his table frequently to ask whether they've been bamboozled.
The Civil War is all the rage now, Anthony said, pricing artifacts out of reach for many collectors. Many are switching to more affordable items from World War II. Most collectors are former members of the military and history buffs, the vendors say.
The memorabilia sale, in its 21st year, is held three times a year in North Carolina, said promoter Richard Shields. Some vendors travel from city to city every weekend; others are occasional traders.
Tony Beasley of Raleigh dropped by to sell a Boy Scout tin canteen and mess kit from the early 1970s, for which he got $10. Beasley also brought a 1972 double-barrel 12-gauge shotgun for sale, hoping to attract a buyer by carrying the gun around with two index cards affixed that proclaimed: "For sale." But timing is all, and Beasley did not cross paths with anyone looking to invest $250 in his 36-year-old shotgun.
Each artifact has a story, some revealed only by a trained eye. One of Anthony's cases displayed Nazi combat medals, apparently identical. But, he explained, earlier editions were nickel-plated iron, gleaming with the might and confidence of the fascist war machine. Toward the end of the war, with metal in short supply, the limping Nazi regime was forced to hand out forlorn-looking versions made of cheap, dull zinc.
Collectors stopped frequently among tables strewn with patches and armbands and other colorful markers of military merit. Racks of freshly polished guns released the rich scent of linseed oil. Uniforms hung motionless not far from a wicked display of Japanese swords.
John Austin of Raleigh came looking for the communications squadron patches he wore during his six years in the U.S. Air Force. After leaving the service in 1992, Austin lost his patches somewhere between his moves to California, Texas, New Jersey, Delaware and Raleigh. For $6, Austin found two of the three patches he was seeking.
"They've got some pretty good stuff here," he said, noting the selection of Hitler Youth knives and other World War II artifacts.
Each new military campaign yields a new batch of memorabilia. Amid Anthony's vast assortment of 10,000 pieces: Iraqi military shoulder patches from Operation Desert Storm, brought back by some unknown soldier.
"Soldiers bring this stuff back as souvenirs," Anthony said. "Some of it is trash, and some of it is treasure."
November 4, 2008
Hitler wine is a £4,000 fake, say historians
The £4,000 bottle of wine that Adolf Hitler allegedly presented to senior officers to mark his 54th birthday is almost certainly a fake, say leading historians.
The red "FÅhrerwein' attracted bids from around the world when it was sold at auction eight days ago.
It was billed as a rare piece of wartime memorabilia - a fascinating relic of the Third Reich which reflected a previously unknown side of Hitler's character.
And with its portrait of the Nazi leader on the label, the Schwarzer Tafelwein certainly looked authentic.
It was allegedly discovered in a garage in France and sold to an anonymous buyer in Ivybridge, Devon, who then decided to sell it on.
Few expected it to fetch more than £500 when it went under the hammer at the auction in Plymouth, so there was some surprise when it went for £3,400 - or £3,995 including the buyer's premium.
The purchaser, who bid by telephone, was a collector who did not want to be identified.
But now it turns out he may have made an expensive misjudgment.
Sir Ian Kershaw, Professor of Modern History at Sheffield University and author of an award-winning two-volume biography of Hitler, said he had been 'immediately sceptical' when reading reports of the sale.
"For one thing, a Tafelwein, a low-class table wine, was, even in 1943, not a particularly dignified present, even allowing for Hitler's scant knowledge of wines," he said.
"Beyond this, an earlier wine bottle carrying a picture of Hitler - or at least a Nazi emblem - had been banned as kitsch.
"I doubt that Hitler, with his strong sense of prestige, would have wanted his mugshot on a wine bottle. In any case, whoever paid £4,000 for this must be mad."
Historian Felix Pryor, who catalogues historical manuscripts for major auction houses, said: "The idea that Hitler went around giving soldiers bottles of wine is utterly farcical.
"He wasn't teetotal - he liked to sip the occasional glass of champagne with his mistress Eva Braun - but he hardly ever drank."
Another specialist, Frank Litz, who has studied Nazi memorabilia, said: "On his 54th birthday in 1943 Hitler was trying to come to terms with the catastrophic loss of the 6th Army at Stalingrad, the bombing war on Germany and the rout of the Afrika Korps.
"Handing out carpetings was more the order of the day than handing out wine."